Knee cartilage repair versus stem cell therapyEstablished cartilage repair using autologous chondrocytes shows 10–17 year durability for focal knee defects; mesenchymal stem cell therapies have not been tested in large-scale trials against them.Established cartilage repair using autologous chondrocytes shows 10–17 year durability for focal knee defects; mesenchymal stem cell therapies have not been tested in large-scale trials against them.
Knee cartilage damage left untreated and when repair helpsCartilage lacks blood vessels, nerve fibres, and lymph channels, so repair cells cannot reach injuries and pain does not warn of damage, allowing lesions to expand silently until they become clinically serious.Cartilage lacks blood vessels, nerve fibres, and lymph channels, so repair cells cannot reach injuries and pain does not warn of damage, allowing lesions to expand silently until they become clinically serious.
OATS Mosaicplasty Knee Recovery TimelineFull recovery from OATS mosaicplasty spans 6–12 months, extending to 12–18 months for competitive sport, because transplanted bone-and-cartilage plugs require time for biological integration and graft maturation.Full recovery from OATS mosaicplasty spans 6–12 months, extending to 12–18 months for competitive sport, because transplanted bone-and-cartilage plugs require time for biological integration and graft maturation.
Ten-Year Success Rates for OATS MosaicplastyTen-year success rates for OATS mosaicplasty span 72–89% in young, active patients; failure rates drop to 12.5–14% in optimal candidates (under 40, lesion under 3 cm²) but rise to 38–40% in older patients with larger defects.Ten-year success rates for OATS mosaicplasty span 72–89% in young, active patients; failure rates drop to 12.5–14% in optimal candidates (under 40, lesion under 3 cm²) but rise to 38–40% in older patients with larger defects.
Who qualifies for MACI knee surgery?Patients aged 18–55 with deep focal cartilage damage (Grade III-IV, >2 cm²) qualify for MACI if their knees are structurally sound—stable ligaments, correct alignment, no generalised osteoarthritis—and conservative treatment has failed. The procedure is two-stage, with extended rehabilitation required.Patients aged 18–55 with deep focal cartilage damage (Grade III-IV, >2 cm²) qualify for MACI if their knees are structurally sound—stable ligaments, correct alignment, no generalised osteoarthritis—and conservative treatment has failed. The procedure is two-stage, with extended rehabilitation required.
Cartilage specialist or general orthopaedic surgeon for a knee defectKnee cartilage repair without correcting underlying malalignment results in reoperation in 47.4% of cases, versus 17.3% when alignment is corrected simultaneously — a surgical integration that general orthopaedic surgeons often omit from initial assessment and planning.Knee cartilage repair without correcting underlying malalignment results in reoperation in 47.4% of cases, versus 17.3% when alignment is corrected simultaneously — a surgical integration that general orthopaedic surgeons often omit from initial assessment and planning.
Choosing between ACI and MACI for cartilage repairMACI cartilage grafts show 90% fill at two years but decline to 49% by ten years; 73% become fibrocartilage rather than the hyaline cartilage needed for durability.MACI cartilage grafts show 90% fill at two years but decline to 49% by ten years; 73% become fibrocartilage rather than the hyaline cartilage needed for durability.
MACI recovery and return to sportMACI recovery takes twelve to eighteen months before high-impact sport. Most patients return to some sport, but only one-third reach their pre-injury level — a gap significantly driven by kinesiophobia, which clinical teams can screen and address through sports psychology support.MACI recovery takes twelve to eighteen months before high-impact sport. Most patients return to some sport, but only one-third reach their pre-injury level — a gap significantly driven by kinesiophobia, which clinical teams can screen and address through sports psychology support.
When cartilage repair is the right choiceCartilage repair is only for younger, active patients with small focal defects who can sustain nine to eighteen months of intensive rehabilitation.Cartilage repair is only for younger, active patients with small focal defects who can sustain nine to eighteen months of intensive rehabilitation.
OATS versus osteochondral allograft for large knee defectsDefect size determines which procedure: OATS, harvesting cartilage plugs from the patient's own knee, suits lesions up to 4 cm²; osteochondral allograft, using donor tissue, handles larger defects without an equivalent size limit.Defect size determines which procedure: OATS, harvesting cartilage plugs from the patient's own knee, suits lesions up to 4 cm²; osteochondral allograft, using donor tissue, handles larger defects without an equivalent size limit.
OATS or MACI for mid-size knee cartilage defectsWithin the 2–4 cm² range, cartilage defects are large enough that a single plug fails to cover them, yet small enough that two repair techniques remain viable: osteochondral autograft restores cartilage and bone in one operation but creates coverage gaps, whilst matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation requires two operations with laboratory…Within the 2–4 cm² range, cartilage defects are large enough that a single plug fails to cover them, yet small enough that two repair techniques remain viable: osteochondral autograft restores cartilage and bone in one operation but creates coverage gaps, whilst matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation requires two operations with laboratory culture but accommodates irregular shapes without gaps.
Osteochondral Allograft for Post-Traumatic Knee DefectsOsteochondral allograft restores both the cartilage surface and the bone beneath in a single operation for post-traumatic knee injuries — a combination other procedures cannot deliver.Osteochondral allograft restores both the cartilage surface and the bone beneath in a single operation for post-traumatic knee injuries — a combination other procedures cannot deliver.